ForgotPassword?
Sign Up
KCI The Anti-Meth Site
Live Chat
Meth Letters & Stories
Tweekerland Meth Speed Bumps
Search this Topic:
Forum Jump
Posts: 11836
Jan 2 09 1:45 PM
Forum Star
Posts: 1742
Jan 2 09 1:49 PM
Posts: 8745
Jan 2 09 7:34 PM
Speedfreak Emeritus
Well, hmm,
I was going to avoid this discussion, but alas, it has once again stirred me to make a few remarks, comments and FWIW, perhaps some opinions.
This topic, like so many others, gets recycled every so often, months, years and occasionally, more often.
I don't think that people who earn degrees, credentials, certification or other standards of recognition need to feel inferior to those who haven't.
I'm a bit reluctant to state the next part because it would easily provide fodder for unbidden back-handed insults. But I think I'm qualified and have earned my right to state opinions, and have paid my dues.
I shot my first hit of speed in 1968, long before many of you were born. I shot my last hit of speed on Sept. 14th 2001, four days after nine eleven. I am not one bit proud of my drug use or addiction. I am ashamed of myself for engaging in maladaptive behavior, selfish years of feeding my addictions, and becoming what I consider a loathsome, ignorant, ill-mannered embarrassment to my family, wife, children, and God. I acted very badly, committed crime, cheated, lied, and did many bad things. I am not one bit proud of any of them. The streets of San Francisco can be cold, mean, perverse, heartless, and nasty. Seriously, I cringe when I see someone brag about how low they went, how far down they pushed their personal bottom, or flaunt the depravity involved in the underground world of drugs, crime, debauchery, hurt and pain, and the endless array of pimps, pushers, and punks taking advantage of the weak, the ill-defended, the simple-minded, and defenseless victims of an unfortunate past.
FWIW, I also have the legitimate credentials. I have earned three college degrees including an M.A. in Education, two California Teaching Credentials, and a few years ago I went back to college for three more years to complete the coursework, test, internship and I am now certified with C.A.A.D.E. as a Certified Addictions Treatment Counselor. My objective in telling you this is so you know where I'm coming from.
So here's the premise: "Can a counselor be any good if s/he has never been an addict?"
The answer, IMHO, is yes. In a clinical setting, knowledge and education are preferable to experience.
"Does this mean that knowledge, degrees, and certification is all it takes?" Nope. It doesn't mean that at all. There are plenty of degreed, certified, and credentialed counselors who are pretty much worthless in their profession.
Also, there are some entry level counselors, without degrees or certification, enrolled in a drug and alcohol studies program, interns, who are great - because they have the personal experience and life skills to make them great.
Let us look at a few other professions. Until the most recent generations, almost all doctors, including OB/GYN doctors were male. They studied medicine, anatomy, physiology, and so many other things, for eight to ten years before earning the title M.D. But they never experienced a period, childbirth or menopause. They really didn't need to.
Many Catholic priests are superior in giving marriage advice - even though they have never experienced the same.
Here in San Francisco, we hosted one of the greatest NFL football teams of all time. When the 49er's Joe Montana threw a football to Jerry Rice it was magic. They were coached by Bill Walsh. Bill taught them how to win football Super Bowls. But Bill Walsh never, ever threw a football and never ever caught a football in the NFL. His personal experience in the matter = ZERO.
Other examples are many.
I'm not about to apologize for the hard work I've done, the hard work I still do every day, and my intentions for continuing the same.
This work is totally unglamorous, unrewarded, unthanked.
But it is honest, needed, and real.
Posts: 5223
Jan 2 09 7:57 PM
Forum Friend
Posts: 1531
Jan 2 09 8:33 PM
Member
Jan 2 09 8:40 PM
Posts: 2217
Jan 2 09 8:44 PM
Senior Member
Jan 2 09 8:46 PM
Jan 2 09 9:43 PM
"Danimal .. I dont get most of what your replies are" me neither Angie again....in the unlikely event that you do "get" me. ....let know what you git/got. the suspence is killing me [leave that one alone] I got you Angie...and your lil' *Promises* too [pg. 83] You continue to be an inspiration and IMO you're the *Promises incarnate*. TY [can I come out of my dog house now?] [you do drum...don't you?..if not you should] a fav. You laugh at me because I'm different I laugh at you beacuse you're all the same ps...an after thought in response to > "Danimal .. I dont get most of what your replies are" by the same token > "Angie .. I don't get most of what flatlanders are" puzzling...
Posts: 2145
Jan 2 09 9:57 PM
Jan 2 09 10:09 PM
Posts: 10156
Jan 2 09 10:28 PM
Such A Supah Lady!
Posts: 811
Jan 3 09 10:09 AM
Jan 3 09 10:22 AM
"the money" not funny. esp. for those raising a family. IMO the counselors are the ones paying e.g. "some are all about" > giving "maybe allot!' and the ones who don't get paid? how many times have they been tested in ways that a good percentage of professionals can't fathom? what are they "all about"?
Jan 3 09 10:34 AM
Jan 3 09 10:47 AM
Posts: 2261
Jan 3 09 11:42 AM
Posts: 5238
Jan 3 09 12:05 PM
Forum Grouch
Jan 3 09 9:28 PM
Sorry for the rant, I guess this has been on my mind for awhile.
Posts: 1863
Jan 3 09 10:19 PM
Share This